
This Zone thing. It’s… interesting.
I guess that’s my nice way of saying I’m… well… less than thrilled with it. I find the weighing and measuring to be tiresome. In fact, it takes a good hunk of the enjoyment out of a meal. Also, maybe I should buy an updated edition of “Enter The Zone,” because some of the nutrition information is a bit out of date.
But, I have a goal, and I’m determined to reach it, so I’m giving this a shot. It’s only been a couple of weeks.
Paleo was easy, wasn’t it?
If I think back to 2009 when I made my shift from vegetarianism to eating Paleo, I’m not sure that was such an easy transition as I would like to believe. For a couple of months, I even tried to Zone my food, and if I remember correctly, that’s what helped me transition a little faster. Zone discourages grains and sugars, even though you can still fit them into your diet. I remember thinking — “A huge salad versus a tiny sandwich? I’ll take the salad, please!” In that way, Paleo and Zone work really well together. All of those leafy greens and yummy vegetables that I enjoy so much are favored heavily by the Zone, so I can eat more of what I really like.
Paleo is Quality. Zone is Quantity
I quickly dropped the Zone from my diet because of the weighing and measuring. I just didn’t like it. Paleo felt more natural. It was and is a lot easier to choose foods knowing what food groups I can and can’t eat than memorizing how many blocks equal what amounts… and so forth and so forth.But that’s because they’re two different things. My first I AM Crossfit coach — JDP — explained it simply: Paleo is the quality of food. Zone is the quantity.
There’s another reason they fit well together.
I managed to avoid full-on Zoning during both of the I AM Crossfit challenges that I participated in because first I was pregnant, then I was breastfeeding — and restricting quantity would not have been wise. I followed rations, and those were ingrained in my head. Carb – 40%, protein 30%, fat 30%.
I tried to make every plate look like that.
My issues with The Zone Diet
The trouble is, I read. A lot. And I read about nutrition. I read Paleo blogs, and I’ve come to really respect what folks like Loren Cordain, Mark Sisson, Robb Wolf and the Whole 9 folks have to say. And some of the things they say don’t jive with what Dr. Sears says.
I think what bothers me the most is how fat-phobic the Zone Diet is. It took me years and years to get rid of my fat phobia, and when I did, I finally started losing fat. Research shows that fat doesn’t make you fat. Fat combined with super-processed sugary foods does, so cutting that junk out of your diet is a huge step in the right direction.
Have you seen the fat amounts on the Zone Diet? We’re talking 3 almonds is a whole block. Or 1/3 tsp of olive oil. That’s quite a difference from what I’m used to just eating Paleo. Plus, I don’t avoid saturated fats. There are benefits to saturated fat from grassfed animals where the ratio of Omega 3′s to Omega 6 fatty acids is much more in balance.
I’m not sure how long I can keep this up
I hosted a Twitter chat at work the other day with one of our health educators. It was all about nutrition and weight loss. I know that the way I eat isn’t exactly mainstream, so I don’t make an issue of it. But somehow the Paleo Diet came up, and the educator said she hated it and had a huge problem with it.
I’m used to those type of comments, so it didn’t ruffle my feathers. Most people can’t get past what ISN’T included in a Paleo lifestyle: Grains, legumes, dairy. Grains is usually the worst offender, because most health professionals believe that whole grains are essential to a healthy diet.
Then, they say stuff like — “Well, cavemen ate grains and roots and all that. These paleo people eat way more meat than what our prehistoric ancestors REALLY ate.” I usually point out that vegetables are the focus and point them to Robb Wolf’s book, because he does an excellent job at dispelling myths about ancient diets.
Then they say stuff like it’s unsustainable, because they don’t know how anyone could live without grains, legumes and dairy. And they’re shocked when I tell them I’m been eating like this for more than 2 years and I feel great. Of course, they don’t understand the 80/20 rule or occasional indulgences. (I should really have my Paleo pitch ready.)
Zone feels much less sustainable at this point. But maybe I’m just looking at it like the Paleo naysayers. I don’t really understand how good I can feel or all of the science, so it’s easier for me to criticize it.
Why I’m sticking with it
But even though I have some issues with the Zone and I find it extremely cumbersome, inconvenient and unsustainable, I’m giving it a shot. Combined with Paleo foods, Zach believes it will help me lose the body fat that I want to lose.
And to be honest, as much as I want to eat that giant steak that Andy grilled up last night for dinner, do I really need 10oz of meat? Unlikely. Limiting my portions to 4 blocks of protein and fat has been a good thing. I no longer feel like I ate way too much 10 minutes after each meal. I feel satisfied. Clean. Well-fueled.
The sugar-monster cometh
That’s not to say that my cravings have decreased. Last night, staring into the chiminea fire with Andy and the kids as they drank hot chocolate with marshmallows, I was pretty much hating the way I eat, but not because of the Zone. That week of eating all the sugar I could handle really messed with me, and my brain is going through a sugar addict’s withdrawal. This is my “Junk-free January.” I REALLY REALLY REALLY want to drink a glass of red wine and eat chocolate. But I’m not going to. Not only would I have to give up a large amount of yummy vegetables in order to Zone that stuff, but it’s not even part of Paleo nutrition.
How about performance?
I can’t say that I’ve noticed a change in performance, but it will likely take time to measure results. And even if results are flat or negative, that doesn’t mean my nutrition is the reason. My sleep is off again thanks to a second job and a million other projects. And I’ve been feeling some stress.
Here’s how my Crossfit workouts went this week.
Tuesday
5 rounds
Row 500m/400m/300m/200m/100m
Ring Rows 25/20/15/10/5
Deadlift 5/4/3/2/1
Time: 15:35 @ 115#
Thursday
A) 5 rounds
4 Shoulder Press
3 Push Press
2 Push Jerk
55# (started at 65# – did 1 round at 60# and had to drop to 55#. Still very challenging!)
B) Tabata Push ups / squats
Score: 12 pushups / 17 squats
Not bad, in my opinion. And if you read my post yesterday on this week’s Olympic Lifting class, you’ll know that progress is being made there, too!
Let’s just give this Zone thing a little time. I’m not going hungry. It doesn’t seem to be hurting anything essential. And I’m open to this experiment, even if it is a little uncomfortable.